How GameSkim Tier Lists Are Made
How GameSkim combines an AI draft with user votes in its tier lists, and when a new character gets its grade.
The starting point is an AI draft
GameSkim tier lists start from a draft written by AI. The draft gives each character a single grade from S to D based on publicly available information, and the date the draft is based on is noted below the list.
The draft is only a starting point. So that a grade does not get locked in by one person's or one outlet's opinion, user votes are added on top to move the grades over time.
How votes move the grades
You can vote for S, A, B, C or D on any character. The grade shown in the list is set by the average of the draft score and user votes, and the draft counts the same as five votes.
For example, if a character drafted as A keeps gathering S votes, the average rises and it moves to S. On the other hand, a vote or two alone will not easily flip a grade. The weight of the draft prevents sudden swings caused by pranks or mistakes.
New characters wait in the '?' row
Characters released after the draft was written have no draft grade. They gather in the '?' row at the bottom of the list, and once three or more votes come in, they receive a grade based on the average and move up the list.
Right after a new character is released, opinions tend to be split, so grades may change often during the first few days. The position becomes more stable as votes accumulate.
Why we mix in votes
Tier lists are shaped by the maker's tastes and play style. A list made by one person is fast and consistent, but it's weak on characters that person hasn't used or on combinations they don't enjoy. Gathering judgments from many players reduces this bias.
However, if a list were built from votes alone, it would start out empty and votes would pile up on popular characters. Giving every character a starting draft and then refining it through votes is a choice to reduce both of these weaknesses.
Order within a tier and categories
Within the same tier, higher-scoring characters appear first. Scores are the average of the draft and the votes, so even within the same A tier, some characters sit close to S and others close to B. Characters placed higher are more likely to move up a tier.
The top characters by category shown below each list pick the five highest-scoring characters for each attribute or role. They're more useful for finding candidates for a role your team needs than for judging overall tiers.
One vote per device, and you can change it anytime
Voting does not require an account, and each device counts only one vote per character. If you change your mind, you can tap the same character again to pick a different grade or cancel your vote.
These tier lists are not official ratings from any game company. They are reference material. If your view differs from the list, that view is exactly what makes the list more accurate, so please add your vote.