How to Read a Tier List: What S to D Actually Means
What the S, A, B, C and D grades in a tier list are based on, and why picking a character by grade alone often goes wrong.
A tier list is a map, not a ranking
A tier list looks like a single line of characters sorted from strongest to weakest, but in practice it works more like a map that groups characters of similar strength together. A character sitting further left inside the S tier is not necessarily stronger, and an A-tier character often beats an S-tier one in certain situations.
So when you read a tier list, it helps to first ask 'which group fits my account and the way I play' rather than 'who is number one'.
What each grade roughly means
S is strong in almost every situation without needing any special conditions. A is strong enough but needs some support, such as a good team comp, gear or practice. B is average performance, a character you can use comfortably if you like them.
C can be used, but it often falls behind other characters in the same role. D is hard to recommend in the current version unless you have a clear reason. Still, a D grade does not mean you cannot clear the game. Most games are built so that you can finish the main content with lower-tier characters.
Why picking by grade alone often fails
First, tier lists usually measure against the hardest endgame content. If you casually follow the story, the difference between grades may hardly be noticeable. Second, many characters look ordinary on their own and only become strong alongside certain teammates. Without those teammates, even an S-tier character may not perform well.
Third, tier lists shift with every version. A new character or a balance patch can turn yesterday's S into today's A. Before you spend currency based on a grade, check what date and version the list is based on.
Tier lists use different criteria
Even for the same game, a tier list's rankings depend on who made it. Some lists measure how fast a character clears the hardest content, some measure how easy a character is for beginners to use, and others measure PvP win rate. Since the criteria differ, it's natural for the results to differ too.
So when reading a tier list, check what it was ranked by before the rank itself. If the list doesn't state its criteria, treat it as a reference only. It's safer to compare two or three lists and look for characters that rank high in all of them.
Growth status changes the rank
Tier list ranks usually assume a character is fully developed and equipped with good gear. A newly obtained character isn't as strong as its rank suggests. Characters that only perform with a signature weapon or duplicate copies should be viewed one or two tiers lower without them.
Conversely, characters that do their job without much investment often feel better in play than their rank suggests. If your resources are limited, check separately how strong a character is with little investment.
Ways to use tier lists well
If you are just starting out, look for S and A characters that are easy to obtain first. If you already have characters you have built up, it is more useful to see where they stand within their own role group than to look only at their overall grade. Filtering by role shows which candidates could fill the empty slots in your team.
Finally, a character you love does not need to be dropped just because it has a low grade. A tier list only tells you about efficiency. What keeps people playing a game for a long time is usually attachment.